Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Healthcare Costs Fuel Election Debate Over the Future of System Reform

With fewer than 100 days until the 2026 midterm elections, state and federal policymakers are preparing for a cycle that

Updated

Jul 29, 2026

Read time

6 min read

Share

With fewer than 100 days until the 2026 midterm elections, state and federal policymakers are preparing for a cycle that may reshape healthcare priorities across the country. Election outcomes will influence budget decisions, legislative agendas, and how officials respond to persistent concerns around affordability, access, and the long‑term stability of public health programs. 

These debates are unfolding as states brace for the effects of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), which is expected to introduce new pressures on state‑administered healthcare systems. Scheduled reductions to major programs, including Medicaid, are likely to force difficult choices during the 2027-2028 legislative session. The stakes are heightened by the sheer volume of electoral activity ahead, with 36 gubernatorial seats and 88 of 99 state legislative chambers on the ballot, positioning healthcare as a central issue for both policymakers and voters. 

Medicaid sits at the center of this conversation because millions of low‑income Americans, children, seniors, and people with disabilities rely on it for coverage. OBBBA’s projected $1 trillion reduction in federal Medicaid spending between 2025 and 2034, driven by work‑reporting requirements, limits on provider tax arrangements, and restrictions on state‑directed payments, is predicted to lead to the immediate loss of coverage for 7-13 million Americans. These changes may also strain healthcare providers, particularly rural hospitals, which already operate with narrow margins and depend heavily on Medicaid revenue. 

At the same time, broader questions about the financial structure of the U.S. healthcare system continue to shape policy discussions. A 2026 study estimated national healthcare spending at $5.28 trillion in 2024, with administrative and non‑clinical costs accounting for roughly $372 billion. Additional studies indicate that the administrative overhead, including fraud, abuse, and profit over patients, creates a waste factor of 25-35%. Rising administrative complexity has become a focal point for leaders seeking greater efficiency and more sustainable governance. As funding streams and payment systems grow more intricate, policymakers and healthcare organizations are increasingly focused on improving coordination and strengthening the systems that support patients, providers, workers, business owners, and communities.

For many policymakers and healthcare analysts, these costs represent a broader question about how resources are allocated across a complex network of insurers, providers, government programs, and administrative systems. Chuck Pennacchio, Ph.D., President of One Payer States, has spent decades examining these issues through the lens of history, economics, and political organizing. A historian and longtime organizer, Pennacchio taught history and politics for 32 years and previously co-founded Healthcare for All Pennsylvania, where he worked on healthcare policy advocacy and coalition development. 

His experience spans labor organizing, public policy campaigns, and economic research related to healthcare reform. Pennacchio views fragmentation among insurers, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, and medical device manufacturers as a significant factor shaping healthcare incentives and administrative complexity. 

In his view, the financial structure of healthcare deserves as much attention as the delivery of care itself. Pennacchio says, “Healthcare reform is ultimately an economic conversation as much as a moral one. The question is how a nation organizes its resources so that healthcare works more efficiently for families, workers, employers, and communities.” 

That economic perspective has influenced the strategy behind One Payer States, an organization founded in 2009 that focuses on developing state-based pathways toward national healthcare. The organization works with a 25-state coalition exploring state-level healthcare models while also supporting federal enabling legislation that would allow states to redirect existing Medicare and Medicaid funding into unified state healthcare pools if they establish qualifying systems.

The 50-State strategy reflects an effort to work within America’s federal structure, where states often serve as environments for policy experimentation and implementation. The organization’s framework draws from publicly funded, privately delivered healthcare models used internationally while considering how similar principles could be adapted within the U.S. healthcare landscape. Its goal is to explore systems where funding, administration, and access are organized differently while restoring patient choice and provider participation.

A significant part of this discussion involves the relationship between healthcare costs and smaller employers. Pennacchio argues that small and mid-sized businesses often experience healthcare expenses differently from larger corporations, many of which use self-funded insurance arrangements. This difference, he believes, creates an important economic consideration for business owners who are seeking predictable costs and the ability to compete both locally and in global markets where their competitors have the advantage of operating in nations with universal healthcare systems.

“The small business community has a powerful stake in understanding healthcare economics,” Pennacchio states. “A healthcare system should be evaluated by how well it supports the people and institutions that depend on it, including the entrepreneurs and workers who contribute to local economies.”

The connection between employment and healthcare access has developed over decades. Theodore Roosevelt’s 1912 presidential campaign included a proposal for social insurance, beginning a longstanding national discussion about healthcare security. Following World War II, employer-sponsored insurance became a defining feature of the U.S. system, creating a relationship between employment and health coverage that has influenced workers’ decisions about careers, entrepreneurship, and mobility. 

Within this broader historical context, One Payer States organizes its engagement across four levels of state readiness. These include states facing significant healthcare access challenges, states with Medicaid expansion programs, states exploring public-option models, and states developing more comprehensive universal healthcare proposals. This framework allows the organization to maintain conversations across different political environments while recognizing that states face different healthcare conditions and policy opportunities. 

 

Pennacchio’s perspective is that state initiatives and federal action can develop alongside one another as policymakers evaluate possible reforms. “Large systems change through decisions made close to the people affected by them,” he remarks. “States can demonstrate ideas, gather evidence, and contribute to future national conversations.” 

As the 2026 elections approach, healthcare remains closely connected to government budgets, household finances, and economic decision-making. The choices made by voters and policymakers will influence how states respond to changing healthcare pressures and evolving expectations around coverage and affordability. 

The broader discussion reflects an ongoing examination of how the United States can organize healthcare resources in a way that supports communities, workers, employers, and providers. As states navigate new fiscal challenges and policy debates, different models for improving healthcare financing and access are likely to remain part of the national conversation.

 

Keep reading

Continue reading